Every four years, football fans become tactical geniuses.
Whether it’s Uncle Graham, Kerry from accounts, or your 5 am taxi ride home, during the tournament, everyone seems to know who should be playing left-back. If only Thomas Tuchel “would just listen!!”
And with World Cup 2026 bringing together 48 teams across Canada, Mexico and the USA, it’s “the biggest World Cup everrrr.” Which means even more room for opinions, drama, and people shouting “bring him on!” at a telly. We love to see it.
Naturally, this got us thinking. If your brand had a Starting XI, who’s actually making the cut? Because a strong brand needs a full squad. Strategy, design, messaging, motion, campaigns, consistency, the lot. Everyone in position, everyone doing their job. And nobody wandering around the pitch wondering what the brief was.
So, let’s pick the team…
Goalkeeper: Brand Guidelines
Not glamorous (unless it’s Nigeria’s offering ofc, IYKYK). But absolutely essential.
Your goalkeeper is the thing stopping chaos from slipping in at the back post. In brand terms, those are your guidelines.
Colours, type, logo usage, tone, layouts, motion principles. The rules that keep your brand from turning into six slightly different versions of itself every time a new campaign goes live.
Are your brand guidelines the flashiest player on the pitch? No. But do people appreciate and respect them enough? Also no.
BUT without them, one person is making a LinkedIn banner in the wrong colour, someone else is using a rogue logo from 2018, and guess what? You’ve scored three own goals before half-time.
Centre-backs: Strategy and positioning
Every solid team needs players who hold the shape. For brands, that’s strategy. The stuff that decides who you are, who you’re for, what you stand for, and why anyone should care.
Without strong positioning, everything further up the pitch starts drifting. Your messaging gets vague, your campaigns feel disconnected, and your visuals look nice but don’t really say anything. i.e., nothing lands.
Essentially, a brand or campaign without a strategy is just a team running around enthusiastically in matching kit. Cute, but no champagne spray in the locker room.
Wing-backs: Motion Lab
Football needs rapid grafters. The ones who don’t just defend but also create chances, cover ridiculous amounts of ground, and somehow still get the ball over the line when it counts. Motion content is a bit like that.
Like a winger, a good animation doesn’t just look good in an ’80s short short. It explains products, brings campaigns to life, makes exhibition stands impossible to ignore, adds energy to social feeds and turns static messaging into something people actually want to watch.
Low-key, it’s the hardest-working player on the team. And yes, we’re slightly biased, just ask the Nutty Professor over in our very own Motion Lab.
Midfield: Campaign creative
This is where games are won. The best midfielders connect everything, i.e. they do the legwork.
Campaign creative does exactly the same. Whether it’s an integrated launch, a global sales toolkit, a product campaign or an event activation, every touchpoint should attract attention and feel like it’s playing the same game.
Let’s be real. The best campaigns don’t look like lots of separate assets. They look like one idea moving effortlessly across every channel, a bit like England’s once-in-a-generation win against Mexico (yasssssssss!). And, without strong, cohesive creative, your campaign is as dead as the Tartan Army’s trophy chances (*sobs in bagpipes*).
Wingers: Messaging & Copywriting
A winger’s job is simple. Create space. Disrupt the status quo. Deliver something worth pushing forward for. That’s messaging, baby.
You can have the best design in the world, but if your headline sounds like every other B2B company claiming to be “innovative” and “customer-centric”, you’ve already lost possession.
Great copy gives your brand personality. It gives people something to remember. And it’s what the people want. More importantly, it gives every other creative asset something meaningful to say.
Turns out words matter after all. Just not the soupy, sloppy AI kinda ones.
Striker: The big idea
Here we go. The one everyone talks about. The one battling it out for the Golden Boot. The one impervious to making a red card stick (but only if your President is as corrupt as your governing body, lol).
The shiny North Star of any campaign is the concept. The hook. The thing that makes it all make sense and allows everything else to be built around it. But here’s the catch: a striker can’t do everything alone. Even the best idea needs service. It needs strategy behind it, good execution around it, and enough consistency to stop it from becoming a one-off scribble on a pub napkin that disappears faster than a José Mourinho apology.
A big idea without support is just a very talented person standing up front, alone, and annoyed. And boy, do these Wunderkinds have a temper.
The manager: Client partnership
Want to hear a secret? The creative agency isn’t an autocratic ruler. You’re on the touchline too.
Our job is to coach, challenge, spot opportunities and occasionally stop an over-excited client from trying to play eleven strikers at once.
The best creative partnerships aren’t built on agencies saying yes to everything. In our experience, they’re built on trust, the confidence to ask awkward questions and a willingness to challenge assumptions. And most importantly, knowing when to stick to the game plan instead of changing formation every five minutes because someone’s Hinge date liked the old version of the logo.
The bench: Useful tools
Every squad needs a bench. AI tools, templates, stock assets, and automation are all useful in the right context. But they shouldn’t be starting every game.
Use them to speed up the boring bits. Use them to support the process. Use them to get from A to B faster when the route is already clear. Just don’t confuse convenience with creativity. If your whole brand is built from whatever was easiest to grab, don’t be surprised when it looks like everyone else’s. Soz.
VAR: Feedback
Ah, VAR. Technically, there to help. Often responsible for sucking all joy (amongst other things) out of the game.* In branding, VAR is feedback. Good feedback improves the work. It connects back to the brief, the audience and the objective.
Bad feedback says things like:
“Can we make it pop?”
“Could it feel more premium?”
“I showed my neighbour’s Doberman, and she didn’t get it.” Useful. Thanks, Brenda.
The best creative process isn’t feedback-free. That would be terrifying and not good for the end result. But it does need structure, context and a small enough group of decision-makers that the idea survives to full-time. For more tips on how to do it well, check this out.
*God speed Egypt x
Man of the match: Consistency
Not the flashiest answer. Sorry.
But consistency is usually what separates a strong brand from a brand that just had one nice campaign once. Consistency makes people recognise you, trust you, and understand what you’re about before you’ve explained it for the fifth time.
And while a big campaign might get the headlines, consistency is what keeps the points ticking over. Just make sure that while you’re being consistent, you’re doing it with a healthy dollop of individualism (more on being consistently individual here).
So, how’s your squad looking?
If your brand’s relying on one star player, it might be time to look at the whole team.
Maybe your visuals are strong, but your messaging is vague. Maybe your campaigns look great, but your website’s letting the side down. Or perhaps your strategy exists somewhere in a PDF nobody has opened since 2021.
No judgement here. Well, maybe only a smidge.
The point is, great brands need balance. They need a clear shape, the right tools, and enough creative confidence to actually play forward. So, before the next big campaign kicks off, ask yourself: Who’s in your Starting XI?
And more importantly…is anyone playing out of position? If so, you know where we are.